Food price caps: why the proposals should be dropped
The Scottish Government published proposals for a food price cap alongside its Programme for Government on 1 September 2026.
While FDF Scotland supports action to help households with the cost of food, we are clear that food price caps are not the answer and the proposals should be dropped. Food price caps fail to address the root causes of food inflation and risk reducing investment, distorting markets, and squeezing a sector already operating on tight margins, ultimately undermining the resilience of Scotland’s food supply chain.
FDF Scotland has responded to the Scottish Government’s consultation and is calling on ministers to abandon the proposals.
We have set out four key reasons why food price caps are the wrong approach.
1. The costs don’t disappear
- Artificially capping food prices does not remove the cost of producing food. Instead, the pressure can be displaced elsewhere in the supply chain, through higher prices on non-capped products, pressure on suppliers or reduced investment.
- Manufacturers have limited capacity to absorb additional costs, with some businesses already making losses on individual products. Expecting them to absorb additional costs is simply not sustainable.
- One Scottish manufacturer reports margins of just 1.5%, while a major dairy processor reports margins of around 1.3%.
- < image here >
- SMEs are likely to be particularly affected, with less capacity to absorb rising costs across their product range.
2. Price caps won’t tackle food inflation
- Food prices reflect the cost of producing and supplying food. Price caps do not address the underlying cost pressures faced by manufacturers.
- Food and drink manufacturing is an energy-intensive sector. UK industrial electricity prices are around twice the European average.
- The sector also faces a growing fiscal and regulatory burden, with taxes and Extended Producer Responsibility costs exceeding £9.9bn in 2025.
- One manufacturer estimates that policy and regulatory changes alone have increased its cost of doing business by £12 million since 2023. This doesn’t include significant rises in energy, fuel and transport costs in recent years.
- Addressing these pressures would do more to tackle food inflation than price controls that risk distorting supply chains and undermining investment.
3. International evidence shows they don’t work
- The Hungarian Central Bank found that price caps introduced in the country in 2022 didn’t contain food inflation, with losses on capped products compensated for with price rises elsewhere.
- In Croatia, the European Commission found that price caps were ineffective in slowing food inflation. Croatian food inflation also remained above EU and euro-area levels for much of the period.
- The OECD has recommended that Croatia phase out the cap as part of its journey towards membership.
4. There are better ways to support households
- Rather than a blanket cap that would have a negative impact on inflation, Ministers should prioritise targeted support for low-income households. This can include expanding affordable school and community food provision, boosting food redistribution, and reinstating support for programmes, such as FareShare’s Surplus with Purpose.
- Breakfast clubs support children and families without adding further pressure to the food supply chain, and government should continue to invest in these. Food and drink manufacturers are also already contributing through funding, food donations and partnerships with schools, charities and government.
Our engagement
FDF Scotland is engaging with the Scottish Government and MSPs to highlight industry concerns about food price caps and has responded to the Scottish Government’s consultation. We will continue to make the case for evidence-based policies that support investment, competitiveness and food security.